The evidence library
Read the record.
Each evidence record identifies its source, date, verification level, what it supports, and what it does not prove. One evidence record may support more than one issue. Anonymous submissions are reviewed before anything is published.
E033firsthand
Current MaxPreps roster and statistics accuracy concern
October 9, 2026 · Current MaxPreps roster and statistics accuracy concern
Current public review shows Ayala JV's MaxPreps page still asks for a team roster submission and states player statistics have not been entered. Ayala varsity statistics show a last update date of September 26, 2026 despite later varsity games. User reports that during announced games, incorrect player names…
What it supportsDocuments ongoing gaps in public roster and statistics maintenance and supports the user's concern that basic player information is not being kept current. It also creates a plausible operational link…
What it does not proveDoes not independently prove which specific player names were announced incorrectly, who supplied the announcer roster, or whether MaxPreps is the source used by the stadium announcer.
E028firsthand
JV athletic trainer coverage concern
September 30, 2026 · JV athletic trainer coverage concern
User reports that no athletic trainer was present on the field during the September 30, 2026 JV football game and that this was the second JV game during the 2026 season without a trainer present. June 2025 booster minutes had previously documented Coach Smith requesting trainer support and…
What it supportsSupports a recurring concern about athletic trainer coverage and student safety, especially because trainer support had been raised with administration in the prior season.
What it does not proveDoes not independently establish why no trainer was present, whether another qualified medical professional was available elsewhere, whether policy required an athletic trainer at that specific JV game, or the…
E026documented
Scheduling inconsistency evidence
September 29, 2026 · Scheduling inconsistency evidence
User reports that Ayala Freshman, JV, and Varsity football did not share the same bye week in 2026, unlike the program pattern the user observed over the prior six to seven years. Public MaxPreps schedules reviewed on September 29 also contained conflicting and duplicated JV dates, while the…
What it supportsSupports documenting a current scheduling coordination concern across football levels and identifies public schedule inconsistencies that should be reconciled against the school's official master schedule.
What it does not proveDoes not prove why bye weeks differed, does not establish that school administration alone controlled all opponent scheduling, and does not independently verify the user's six to seven year historical…
E019documented
Official Board meeting minutes
May 1, 2025 · Official Board meeting minutes
May 1, 2025 regular meeting minutes documenting Ayala football coach supporters
What it supportsMinutes list Terrance Smith among public speakers. Board Member John Cervantes acknowledged support for the Ayala HS coach, and Board Member James Na thanked Ayala HS football program supporters for…
What it does not proveMinutes do not summarize each speaker's individual remarks and do not establish why Smith was released or rehired.
E018documented
Official Board meeting minutes
June 5, 2025 · Official Board meeting minutes
June 5, 2025 regular meeting minutes
What it supportsMinutes expressly note student participation in support of Ayala High's athletic director. Board Member James Na asked Superintendent Enfield to speak with the athletic director about reconsidering his resignation, and…
What it does not proveThe minutes do not summarize what each public speaker said or establish why Reed resigned.
E017documented
Independent news report
May 23, 2025 · Independent news report
Report on Ayala athletic department turmoil and May 23 protest
What it supportsReports that about 60 parents and athletes protested outside Ayala on May 23, many carrying signs supporting Warren Reed or coaches; also reports Smith's firing and later rehiring and broader…
What it does not proveDoes not by itself prove the protesters' allegations, administrative motive, or legal wrongdoing.
E013documented
Public website
September 29, 2026 · Public website
Ayala varsity football public page
What it supportsThe public page displayed a team page last update date of September 15, 2026 and current schedule/results information when reviewed.
What it does not proveDoes not by itself establish which specific player statistics were missing or who was responsible for updating them.
E009documented
Public petition
May 1, 2025 · Public petition
Reinstate Coach Terrance Smith as Ayala Football Head Coach
What it supportsContemporaneous public opposition existed, the petition described a hiring and removal sequence, and the page later displayed victory with 525 supporters.
What it does not proveThe petition's claims of wrongful treatment, targeting, transfers or motive are advocacy claims, not independently verified facts.
